Status of CC Analysis Blessed Plots Updated: Feb 1, 06


  1. Introduction

    To do: add in nd/numi
    1. Status: blessed
      Plot: FD Construction Photo
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/photos/construction-02-343.jpg
      Documentation: None
      Description:
      Photo of the front of the MINOS Far Detector taken during construction in Spring 2002. (Photo credit: Fermilab Visual Media)


    2. Status: blessed
      Plot: FD Front view Photo
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/photos/frontview-03-381.jpg
      Documentation: None
      Description:
      Photo of the MINOS Far Detector taken in Summer 2003. (Photo credit: Fermilab Visual Media)


    3. Status: blessed
      Plot: FD Side view Photo
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/photos/sideview-03-370.jpg
      Documentation: None
      Description:
      Photo of the side of the MINOS Far Detector taken in Summer 2003. (Photo credit: Fermilab Visual Media)



  2. Blessed NuMI Beam Plots

    Selection from the Beam Systematics Paper (NuMI-1283). No objection to any of the plots in it for techincal talks but for main MINOS conference talks we would propose the following: (note some need some work to make the eps file to have all the feastures from the proposed slides Many were annotated and turned into proposed slides in http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/numi-blessed-plots-proposal.ppt
    1. Status: blessed - could use work
      Plot: Schematic showing 5 beam trajectories
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/5-beams.eps Would like a version in eps that looks like P2 of http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/numi-blessed-plots-proposal.ppt
      Documentation: NuMI-1283, Fig 2 (lower), p3.
      Description:
      Schematic of 5 categories of focused pions: (1) very high energy pions pass through the necks of both horns at small angles, contributing to the high energy tail; (2) slightly softer pions exit the target at small enough angle to pass through the neck of horn 1, but are focused by horn 2; (3) the next softest category of pions enters horn 1, is underfocused (i.e. is still diverging as it exits horn 1), but is brought into focus by horn 2 (this category constitutes the vast majority of the flux in the LE beam); (4) still softer pions enter horn 1 are soft enough to be brought into focus entirely by horn 1 and pass (parallel) through the (larger) neck of horn 2; and (5) the softest pion momenta contributing to the neutrino flux consists of pions which are actually over-focused by horn 1 and are rescued by horn 2


    2. Status: blessed - would like improvments in the eps file
      Plot: Example pion trajectories
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/LE10focusing.eps Would like a version in eps that looks like P3 of http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/numi-blessed-plots-proposal.ppt
      Documentation: Numi-1283, Fig 1, page 2
      Description:
      A plot of...


    3. Status: Blessed - don't have the source
      Plot: Horizontal Beam width
      Current Link: Need link
      Documentation: Numi-1283, Fig 11 (left), page 11,13
      Description:
      Plots show horizontal beam width data accumulated over the period of few months. Beam quality cuts are applied.


    4. Status: Blessed - don't have the source
      Plot: Vertical Beam width
      Current Link: Need a link
      Documentation: Numi-1283, Fig 11 (right), page 11,13
      Description:
      Plots show vertical beam width data accumulated over the period of few months. Beam quality cuts are applied.


    5. Status: Blessed
      Plot: Beam width
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/frac-beam-miss-target.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, Fig 12 (right), page 11,13
      Description:
      The fraction of the beam missing the target.


    6. Status: needs work but blessed
      Plot: Beam width
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/profile_s1.2_int15.5.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, Fig 12 (left), page 11,13
      Description:
      The profile of the protons incident on the target for a pulse with 1.1mm width. The target subtends the region -4.2mm to 2.1mm. We see that there are some protons miss the target. The baffle covers the region from -5.6mm to 5.5mm. Need to get the EPS to include "Shaded area on the represents the width of the target"


    7. Status: blessed - not linked yet
      Plot: Hadron production model spread
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/
      Documentation: Numi-1283, fig 42
      Description:
      Hadron production model spread (Fig 42)


    8. Status: blessed
      Plot: Near Spectrum + errors
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/spect_le10_near.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, fig 42
      Description:
      Near Spectrum + errors


    9. Status: blessed
      Plot: Error on Far over Near ratio
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/err_le10_farovernear.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, page ??
      Description:
      Error on Far over Near ratio (THIS NEEDS TO BE MADE IN ROOT)


    10. Status: blessed
      Plot: Components of the Near Spectrum
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/LE10_FluxNear_log.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, page ??
      Description:
      Components of the Near Spectrum


    11. Status: blessed
      Plot: Components of the Far Spectrum
      Current Link: http://www.hep.utexas.edu/numi/beamMC/blessed-plots/LE10_FluxFar_log.eps
      Documentation: Numi-1283, page ??
      Description:
      Components of the Far Spectrum



  3. NuMI performance

    1. Status: blessed
      Plot: Far Detector beam neutrino event vs time
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/brian/numi_plots/jpeg/farrate.jpg
      Documentation: Numi-xxxx, page y
      Description:
      A plot of Far Detector beam neutrino event rate in 4 week blocks


    2. Status: blessed - why the weird points?
      Plot: Near Detector beam neutrino event rate vs time
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/brian/numi_plots/jpeg/nearrate.jpg
      Documentation: Numi-xxxx, page y
      Description:
      A plot of Near Detector beam neutrino event rate in 4 week blocks


    3. Status: to be blessed
      Plot: ND/FD Detector beam neutrino event rate vs time
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/brian/numi_plots/jpeg/nearfarrate.jpg
      Documentation: Numi-xxxx, page y
      Description:
      A plot of near & far detector beam neutrino event rate in 4 week blocks


    4. Status: to be blessed
      Plot: ND/FD Detector beam neutrino event rate vs time (overlay)
      Current Link: http://www.hep.ucl.ac.uk/%7Ejthomas/blessed/brian/numi_plots/jpeg/nearfaroverlay.jpg
      Documentation: Numi-xxxx, page y
      Description:
      A direct comparison of the near & far detector beam neutrino event rate in 4 week blocks



  4. MC Description : NEEDS SOME WORK

    1. Any generateor level plots in here
    2. Any specific detector simulation plots

  5. Calibration Detector

    1. EM response plot
    2. Hadron response plots
    3. 1% calibration possible???

  6. Calibration

    need to incorporate plots from Jeff
    1. Before and after calibration (Jeff)
    2. Response vs Z and projection to show width (Jeff)

  7. Preselection

    1. blessed Track Ph/plane ND Data/MC
    2. blessed Track Ph/plane FD Data/MC
    3. not blessed Event Ph/plane ND Data/MC
    4. not blessed Event Ph/plane FD Data/MC
    5. not blessed Shower Ph/strip ND Data/MC
    6. not blessed Shower Ph/strip FD Data/MC
    7. not blessed Track Ph/strip ND Data/MC
    8. not blessed Track Ph/strip FD Data/MC
    9. not blessed Fraction of event PH in 1st 3 planes ND
    10. not blessed Fraction of events PH in 1st 3 planes FD
    11. not blessed Fraction of event PH in planes 3-6 ND
    12. not blessed Fraction of events PH in planes 3-6 FD
    13. not blessed Fraction of event PH in planes 6-last ND
    14. not blessed Fraction of events PH in planes 6-last FD
    15. not blessed; 2D + profile points Momentum from range vs curvature ND
    16. not blessed Momentum from range vs curvature FD
    17. blessed q/p/sigmaq/p ND
    18. not blessed q/p/sigmaq/p FD
    19. blessed Track cosine x ND
    20. not blessed Track cosine x FD
    21. blessed Track cosine y ND
    22. not blessed Track cosine y FD
    23. blessed Track cosine z ND and Track cosine z FD
    24. blessed Track x vertex position for tracks
    25. blessed Track y vertex position for tracks
    26. blessed Event timing FD
    27. not blessed; gives impression of background domination; maybe 2D with a cut shown to show separate; David to propose alternative Event timing of 159 fiducial neutrino candidates with cosmics for comparison
    28. blessed Event vertices FD
    29. blessed Events per pot
    30. blessed Events as a function of time FD

  8. CC / NC Separation

    1. Get newest plots w/o KS, preliminary, show cut; plot by energy slices (0-5, 5-10,10+) PDF for PID
    2. Show cut; plot by energy slices as above PDF for ANN
    3. blessed; some discussion but consistent with 2% ; N/F MC of this; error is error on the mean; add a 2D plot?; events not too important in oscillations Range and Curvature MC/Data ND
    4. blessed but very techincal; Try to optimize binning to strip width?; Different PE cuts Shower width for events with track > 40 planes
    5. blessed; also add in w/o track cut Shower length for events with track > 40 planes
    6. blessed but very techincal; add in w/o the length cut Track length for events with track > 40 planes
    7. blessed but very techincal; add in w/o the length cut ? Track qp for tracks with > 40 planes
    8. blessed but very techincal; add in w/o the length cut ? Overlap between ANN and PID selection

  9. DETECTOR RESPONSE STUDIES

    Some more work on these; fonts; significant figures; content looks OK - will update
    1. event spectra for different run periods
    2. slice studies
    3. batch study of Total energy
    4. batch study of Track Momentum
    5. batch study of Shower energy
    6. Total Energy for different regions of Z
    7. Track momentum for different regions of Z
    8. Shower Energy for different regions of Z
    9. Total Energy for different quadrants
    10. Track momentum for different quadrants
    11. Shower Energy for different quadrants
    12. Annuli studies
    13. Lateral Shower Comparison MC/Data ND no p.e.cut and and with a 2 p.e. cut and and with a 3 p.e. cut
    14. not blessed; with a pulse height cut? Number of strips in shower

  10. Physics Results

      add in Niki's by month plots;
    1. To be blessed Total energy all data le-10 by month
      To be blessedTotal energy all data le-10 by month
      To be blessedTotal energy all data le-10 by month
      To be blessedTotal energy all data le-10 by month
    2. To be blessedMC True CC -> MC CC Only ??; larger fonts; version both with dead reconning MC and with tweaked beam MC
    3. blessed Total energy all pot le-10
    4. blessed Shower energy all pot le-10
    5. blessed Muon momentum all pot le-10
    6. blessed y distribution all pot le-10
    7. blessed Total energy all pot pme
    8. blessed Shower energy all pot pme
    9. blessed Muon momentum all pot pme
    10. blessed y distribution all pot pme
    11. blessed Total energy all pot phe
    12. blessed Shower energy all pot phe
    13. blessed Muon momentum all pot phe
    14. blessed y distribution all pot phe
    15. Toms plots (Fig 48-52) (Tom)