Technical Component Reviews
Button to Fermilab Home Page
Button to NuMI-MINOS Home Page Menu Bar Nu Oscillation Image
Button to Project General Documentation Page Button to NuMI at Work Page Button to MINOS at Work Page Button to Contacts and Email Page Button to NuMI Notes Document Repository Page Button to Fermilab at Work Page
Header Base image

Technical Component Reviews

Upcoming  |  Proposed  |  Completed |

Proposed:     1.1.1  |  1.1.2   |  1.1.3  |  1.1.4   |  1.1.5   |  1.1.7   |  Kicker   |  Integration   |

 

                                                May  25, 2001
                                        revised Oct  28, 2003


         Internal reviews of NuMI Technical Components
         Installation Reviews of NuMI/MINOS Devices
         ---------------------------------------------

DESIGN REVIEWS:
We are in the process of closing out design reviews by responding to previous 
review comments. 
NuMI/MINOS REVIEWS:
A combined list of reviews needed and completed for NuMI and MINOS is posted at
this link. It includes design reviews, installation reviews, operation reviews and ESH/QA reviews. Often parts of the reviews overlap. (see this link for a list of completed technical component design reviews.)
REVIEW PROCESS/SCHEDULE:
Below is a list of review dates and reviewers for various technical
reviews of NuMI Beam line technical components. 

These reviews are coordinated by Bruce Baller, Nancy Grossman, Rich Andrews
and/or Gina Rameika.

Nominally, review of each topic will be proceeded as:
    o Assessment review
    o interim review
    o final DESIGN review
    o Installation/operation review as necessary (often for a system)

Review materials will be posted on the web, to the extent possible, and the web
address sent to the reviewers in advance.  The reviewers will be requested to 
send their comments within one week from the review day.

All reviews will be open to everyone in NuMI Project and MINOS
collaboration.  Any interested individuals can and are welcome to attend
and send their comments.

Final reviews may consist of responding to comments from previous reviews and
informing the reviewers of the where they can view the responses.

Back to Top of Page



 

PROPOSED REVIEW DATES AND REVIEWERS FOR DESIGN REVIEWS
----------------------------------

Back to Top of Page

1.1.1 Primary Beamline ===== Primary beamline Magnet System Contents: System design & installation Interim: Apr 2, 23-24, 2002 Director's Reviews **DONE** Final: Nov 1, 2002 (Beam Optics & magnet power supply) **DONE** Final response to comments: **DONE** Mar/Apr, 2003 (Beam Optics & magnet power supply) Reviewers: Dave Capista, Bob Ducar, Tom Kobilarcik, Jerry Leibfritz, Dave McGinnis, Joel Misek, Shekhar Mishra, Dave Pushka, Wes Smart Primary beamline instrumentation & Beam Permit System (see below) Assessment: July 26, Aug 14 2001 **DONE** Interim: Oct 14 2002 **DONE** Interim: Mar 4, 2003 (Main Injector/NuMI BPM Review) **DONE** Final: Oct 24, 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: Jim Crisp, Paul Czarapata, Rick Ford, Mike Gerardi, Greg Vogel, Wally Kissel, Phil Martin, Gina Rameika, Nancy Grossman, Rich Neswold, Craig Moore, Ralph Pasquinelli, Stan Pruss, Bob Webber, Kamran Vaziri, Jim Zagel Reviewers Oct 2002 (multiwire design focus) Terry Anderson, James Crisp, Rick Ford, Dave Johnson, Karen Kephart, Walter Kissel, John Krider, Eric Prebys, Rob Reilly, Vic Scarpine, Dan Schoo, Gianni Tassotto Reviewers for Oct 24, 2003 review, see review web page (http://www-numi.fnal.gov/numwork/reviews/oct_2403.html). Beam Optics & magnet power supply specification Contents: Calculation with magnet + power supply, beam stability, regulation Assessment: Jun 28 2001 2:00-4:00 **DONE** Interim: Dec 11 2001 **DONE** Interim 2: Sep 2002 (MI/NuMI interfacing focus) **DONE** Final: Nov 1 2002 (beamline sensitivities) **DONE** Reviewers: Phil Martin, Craig Moore, Shekhar Mishra, Don Edwards, Mike Syphers Elvin Harms, George Krafczyk, Alexandr Drozhdin, John Johnstone Mike Gerardi, Mike Andrews Reviewers (Sep 2002): Craig Moore, Shekhar Mishra, David Johnson, Alberto Marchionni, Alexandr Drozhdin, John Johnstone, Terry Anderson, Bruce Baller Reviewers (Nov 2002): George Krafczyk, David Johnson, Paul Czarapata, John Johnstone, Jim Hylen, Wes Smart, Ming-jen Yang Beam Extraction Permit System (also see Primary beam instrumentation review) Assessment: Aug 17, 2001 **DONE** Final: Dec 2003 NEED Reviewers: Phil Martin, Shekhar Mishra, Ralph Pasquinelli, Stan Pruss, Dave Capista, Gerry Jackson, Greg Vogel, Charles Briegel, Paul Czarapata, Wally Kissel, Bob Mau, Dave Johnson, Mike Andrews, Doug Michael, Rob Plunkett, Nancy Grossman, Gina Rameika, Adam Para, Craig Moore Kicker Fluorinert Cooling System Design The purpose of this review is to collectively and constructively evaluate the final design plans and details for this very critical cooling system. Interim/Final June 14, 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Sam Childress, Bob Ducar, Ray Lewis, Dave Pushka, Rob Reilly, John Riordan, Karl Williams BPM - use of digital down conversion electronics Review requirements for NuMI BPMs and hear presentations from RF&I on the use of digital down conversion (DDS) BPM's in order to try to determine what is appropriate for NuMI. June 25, 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Sam Childress, Craig Moore, Valeri Makeev, Gianni Tassotto, James Crisp, Jim Zagel, Mike Church, Bob Webber, Peter Prieto, Brian Chase, Ralph Pasquinelli

Back to Top of Page

1.1.2 Neutrino Beam Devices ===== Target and Target baffle Assessment: Dec 18 2001 (final for target) **DONE** Final: Aug 1 2002 (Baffle, baffle & target carrier) **DONE** Reviewers (Assessment): BSpAG, Bob Bernstein, Dave Pushka, Sam Childress, Peter Lucas, Bruce Baller Reviewers (Design & engineering): Mark Messier, Kris Anderson, Andy Stefanik, Vladimir Sidorov, Sam Childress, Jim Kilmer, Pat Hurh, Dave Ayres, Victor Zarucheyskiy Horn design, prototype & production program Asessment: April 18 1998 **DONE** Interim: April 16 1999 **DONE** Final: Aug 10 2001 9:00-12:00 **DONE** Reviewers: Andy Stefanik, Dave Pushka, Bob Wands, Mark Reichanadter, Ioanis Kourbanis, Larry Bartoszek, Danny Snee, Fritz Lange Shielding of neutrino beam device area Assessment: Jul 27 2001 9:00-12:00 **DONE** Final: covered in Radiation Safety Review Reviewers: John Anderson, Mike Gerardi, Dave Pushka, Nancy Grossman, Lee Hammond, Harry Ferguson, Russ Rucinski, Tony Leveling, Gina Rameika, Cat James, TJ Sarlina, Mike Andrews, Bob Bernstein Instrumentation & monitoring in target hall (includes BDOT & cross hairs) Assessment: Oct 18 2001 **DONE** Final: Nov 18 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Craig Moore, Phil Martin, Rick Ford, Gina Rameika, Adam Para, Gary Feldman, Sam Childress, Sacha Kopp, Bob Bernstein, Alberto Marchionni Reviewers (Nov 2002): Rick Ford, Adam Para, Frank Nezrick, Bob Ducar, Al Legan, Lee Hammond, Brain Kramper Target Hall Air System Final: Aug 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Pushka, Kris Anderson, Rick Ford, Peter Kasper, Gary Lautenschlager, Alexander Martinez, Rich Stanek, Del Allspach, Lee Hammond & Bob Ducar Hot Horn Handling Review Interim: Aug 2001 **DONE** Final: Feb 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Boehnlein, Don Cossairt, Mike Gerardi, Fritz Lange, Phil Martin, Mike May, Rob Reilly Final Reviewers (2002): Dave Ayres, Dave Boehnlein, Don Cossairt, Rob Reilly

Back to Top of Page

1.1.3 Power Supplies ===== Horn Transmission Line Assessment: Jul 10 2001 9:00-12:00 **DONE** Interim: Feb 26 2002 **DONE** Final: Apr 23 2003 1:00-3:00 2NE **DONE** Reviewers: Mike May, Kris Anderson, Howie Pfeffer, Steve Hays, Chris Jensen, Bill Markel, Dave Pushka, Phil Martin, Jim Kilmer, Jim Hylen, Frank Nezrick Final Reviewers (2003): Kris Anderson, Bill Markel, Dave Pushka, Jim Hylen, Frank Nezrick, Dave Tinsley, Ken Bourkland Horn Power Supply (as part of horn system review initially) Assessment: Apr 18 1998 **DONE** Interim: Apr 16 1999 **DONE** Final: Aug 13 2001 **DONE** Magnet Power Supply Assessment: Jul 11 2001 **DONE** Final: Nov 1, 2002 (Beam Optics & magnet power supply) **DONE** Final response to comments: Mar/Apr, 2003 (Beam Optics & magnet power supply) **DONE**

Back to Top of Page

1.1.4 Absorber ===== Decay pipe & Windows Contents: cooling, radiation level, vacuum, ES&H review readiness Assessment: Jul 9 2001 2:00- 5:00 12NW **DONE** Final: Final reviews follow FESHM, Decay Pipe completed in May 2002 Reviewers: Jim Klen, Mike Gerardi, John Anderson, Tony Leveling, Nancy Grossman, Doug Jensen, Rich Stanek, Bob Sanders, Sam Childress, Gina Rameika, Mike Andrews Hadron Absorber Contents: design, cooling, monitoring, installation Assessment: Jun 12 2001 **DONE** Final: Nov 20 2001 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Eartly, Mike Gerardi, Tony Leveling, Jim Kilmer, Mike Andrews, Mark Reichanadter, TJ Sarlina, Sacha Kopp, Dan Johnson, Kris Anderson

Back to Top of Page

1.1.5 Beam Monitoring ===== Beam Monitoring System Assessment: Dec 10 2001 **DONE** Interim: Jul 24, 2002 9-12 1 North **DONE** Final: Mar 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: Gary Feldman, Alberto Marchionni, Jim Hylen, Vittorio Paolone, Doug Michael, Stan Wojcicki, Bob Bernstein, Adam Para Reviewers (July 2002): Mike Gerardi, Kamran Vaziri, Jim Hylen, Pat Hurh, Alberto Marchionni, Stephen Pordes, Wes Smart, Mike Andrews, Dave Pushka

Back to Top of Page

1.1.7 Infrastructure ===== Integrated picture Contents: Cooling, HVAC, fire protection, FIRUS, ICATV, access requirements, personnel limits including their controls and monitoring Assessment: Jul 12 2001 (part I) 9:00-12:00 12NW **DONE** Jul 20 2001 (partII) 9:00-12:00 12NW **DONE** Final: Mar 6 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Capista, Duane Plant, Dan Johnson, Steve Hays, Russ Rucinski, Rob Plunkett, TJ Sarlina, Cat James, Sam Childress, Jim Hylen, Nancy Grossman, Mike Andrews RAW systems Assessment: Oct 24 2001 **DONE** For remainder of RAW reviews, see below. Reviewers: Duane Plant, Dan Johnson, Steve Hays, Russ Rucinski, John Peoples, Mike Gerardi, Nancy Grossman, Tony Leveling, Gina Rameika, TJ Sarlina, Mike Andrews Water Systems Validation Review (LCW, RAW) US LCW Final Sep/Oct 2002 (US LCW) **DONE** RAW Systems Nov 2002 (Horns) **DONE** RAW Systems Oct/Nov 2003 (Target) in progress RAW Systems Oct/Nov 2003 (Hadron Absorber) in progress RAW Systems Oct/Nov 2003 (Decay) in progress Reviewers US LCW: Maurice Ball, Richard Schmitt Reviewers Horn RAW: Maurice Ball, Richard Schmitt, Jim Hylen, Mike Gerardi Reviewers Hadron Absorber RAW: Maurice Ball, Richard Schmitt, Cat James, Mike Gerardi Reviewers Decay Pipe RAW: Maurice Ball, Richard Schmitt, Cat James, Mike Gerardi Reviewers Target RAW: Maurice Ball, Richard Schmitt, Jim Hylen, Mike Gerardi Decay Vacuum System Validation Review Final: May 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: Jim Klen, Bill Soyars

Back to Top of Page

1.1.1 & 1.1.3 Kicker ============= Kicker magnets and Kicker power supply Interim: Feb 1 2002 **DONE** Final: Jul 1, 2002 1-3pm 1N **DONE** Final (BD/EE support): Mar/Apr 2003 (ongoing series of meetings) **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Capista, Elvin Harms, George Krafczyk, Fritz Lange, Terry Anderson, Bruce Hanna, Dave Pushka, Bob Ducar Reviewers (July 2002): George Krafczyk, Paul Czarapata, Greg Vogel, Bruce Hanna, Bob Ducar, Dave Pushka, Dave Johnson, Dave Tinsley, Bill Boettinger Reviewers Final (BD/EE support): George Krafczyk, Dan Wolff (more?)

Back to Top of Page

System integration ================== Workshop on Integrated Installation schedule Part 1 upstream Sep 5 2001 **DONE** Part 2 upstream Sep 27 2001 **DONE** Part 3 downstream Oct 25 2001 **DONE** Integrated Installation Schedule Review Part 4 Review Mar 20-21 2002 **DONE** Director's Review, Dec 4 2002 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Ayres, Bob Brooker, Delmar Miller, Pat Hurh, Joel Misek, John Voirin Workshop on Risk Assessment Part 1 Apr 2002 **DONE** Part 2 Oct 8 2002 **DONE** Commissioning plan of primary beam and neutrino devices Assessment: Oct 19 2001 **DONE** Interim: Nov 5 2002 (workshop) **DONE** Final: Sent out for comments in Nov 2002, received March **DONE** Reviewers 2001: Shekhar Mishra, Dave Johnson, Dave Capista, Phil Martin, Stan Pruss, Herman White, Rick Ford, Wally Kissel, Bob Mau, Gerry Jackson Sent for comments 2002: Shekhar Mishra, Dan Johnson, Bob Mau, Gina Rameika, Stan Wojcicki Review of Accident Conditions Assessment Nov 28 2001 **DONE** Interim/Final Mar 2003 **DONE**

Back to Top of Page

Radiation safety reviews Contents: Shielding, including BLBM, environment monitoring system, air activation, ground water protection, RSS Assessment: Jul 17, 2002 1-3pm **DONE** Final: Jul 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: John Anderson, Mike Gerardi, Sam Childress, Alan Wehmann, Wayne Schmitt, Gina Rameika, Mike Andrews, Craig Moore, Kamran Vaziri, Byron Lundberg, Don Cossairt Integrated Look at Controls Assessment: Part of Infrastructure Reviews Interim: Mar 2003 (Level 3 manager review) **DONE** Final: Apr 2003 **DONE** Reviewers: Dave Capista, Geoff Pearce, Alec Habig, Pete Borders, Ralph Pasquinelli, Paul Czarapata, Craig Moore, John Elias, Marvin Johnson, Wally Kissel, Bob Mau Reviewers Final: Greg Vogel, Casey Seino, Al Franck, Dan Stenman, Al Legan, Paul Allcorn, Brian Kramper

Back to Top of Page

Installation Reviews ==================== US Installation (See link to review web site) **DONE** DS Installation (See link to review web site) **DONE** *****************************************************************************
Follow this link to get to completed reviews.

 

Back to Top of Page

 


 



Send suggestions or comments to - the Pagemaster

Page last updated Tuesday, October 14, 2003

Security, Privacy,Legal

Fermi National
	    Accelerator Laboratory